Celestino’s Pizza & Ristorante Celebrates Ribbon Cutting in New Providence

By Bobbie Peer

Published December 7, 2025 at 5:05 PM

NEW PROVIDENCE, N.J. — Celestino’s Pizza & Ristorante celebrated its official ribbon cutting on Saturday, formally recognizing the restaurant’s summer opening in New Providence. The family-owned business, which also operates a location in Cedar Grove, has transformed the former Coppola’s Restaurant space with updated lighting, refreshed colors, and new decorative moldings, creating a modern and inviting atmosphere for guests.

Jay Udrija, who operates the New Providence restaurant, welcomed guests alongside his brother, Darryl, who runs the Cedar Grove location. Both restaurants offer the same menu of Italian favorites, including Celestino’s signature pizzas, and an extensive catering menu designed to accommodate a wide range of tastes and events. Click here to view menus.

“We opened the last week of July, and the response has been amazing,” Jay said. “It’s the same food as our Cedar Grove restaurant, but with a fresh new look here. We want everyone to feel at home while enjoying Italian cuisine.”

Mayor Al Morgan joined the celebration, cutting the ribbon alongside Jay, Darryl, their families, and staff. Councilman Matt Cuminskey and Councilwomen Nadine Geoffroy and Kathleen Dolan were also in attendance, along with New Providence Biz President Michele Elefante and Lisa Barfield.

“We’re delighted to welcome Celestino’s to New Providence,” Mayor Morgan said. “It’s exciting to see a family-owned business bring great food, a fresh look, and a strong sense of community to our town. We wish them continued success and know they’ll be a favorite for residents for years to come.”

The New Providence location also offers free delivery to surrounding towns through its own drivers—an added convenience noted by guests, who praised both the updated ambiance and the quality of the menu.

Celestino’s now operates in the former Coppola’s Restaurant, a beloved New Providence staple for more than 40 years. Jay emphasized the importance of building strong community connections and becoming a true part of the town. He added that the welcoming dining space and convenient delivery service make it easy for residents to enjoy quality Italian cuisine, whether dining in or ordering from home.

Celestino’s Pizza & Ristorante is located at 590 Central Ave., New Providence. Visit their website or call 973-566-1078.  Follow them on Facebook and Instagram at @celestinospizza.